logoalt Hacker News

Loughlayesterday at 9:14 PM1 replyview on HN

If you ignore all the metal every place around everywhere, then yeah it's harder to get to.

I have to believe we would be able to make due with the available mountains of metal that is already in use in things?


Replies

paimapiyesterday at 10:08 PM

it largely depends on the metal but the issue is with quality, not amount. plus, you don't have much in the way of just iron items these days - you have steel which requires temps quite a fair bit above what's possible in a charcoal/coal-based forge to work. early copper metallurgy utilized ores that were 10%+ metals - much softer, more malleable. these days we work with less than a single percent (but from much larger veins). much smarter people have written about this than me: https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2025GsGe....400323M/abstra...

a better focus would probably be on the fact that there's no longer really easily accessible coal anymore, much less oil. there also are far less trees by which you can make charcoal and firewood (except in certain areas) and that's actually fairly important when it comes to crafting and technology: https://www.postcarbon.org/can-civilization-survive-these-st...

show 1 reply