logoalt Hacker News

contubernioyesterday at 11:52 AM2 repliesview on HN

As a math professor, I care much more about the key idea, heuristics, and motivation than the proof. With the others in place the proof is clear, something an AI or a student can do.


Replies

sigbottleyesterday at 12:28 PM

Well, it's knowing when to push and when to not. You probably have an intuition for, I don't know, abstract algebra objects (I don't know your field of specialty :P), without needing to symbolically manipulate all of it, but you developed a deep intuition for them through many proofs and attempts at proofs with them.

show 1 reply
lupireyesterday at 1:26 PM

That's leaning into engineering, away from math. Heuristics aren't always accurate. Math history before proof is the history of delusion. Idea, heuristics, and motivation aren't nearly enough for correctness outside of a sandbox.