logoalt Hacker News

vrypantoday at 12:39 PM4 repliesview on HN

Not to mention that I can also tell when a poster has been generated using Photoshop and not real artist tools, like brushes and pens. I've seen a lot of these Photoshop-generated posters, and they are in no way comparable to something DaVinci or Picasso would create.


Replies

driverdantoday at 12:45 PM

> not real artist tools

Nice no true Scotsman fallacy. PS is a "real" artist tool.

show 3 replies
miyojitoday at 1:42 PM

This bullshit disingenuous false equivalency again.

In both photoshop and painting, the human using the tool decides what strokes to use. That isn't true with AI art. It's not "just another tool" for doing the activity when it does the entire activity for you.

show 4 replies
cruffle_duffletoday at 6:27 PM

If the hole in the wall teriyaki restaurant’s menu wasn’t hand painted by Monet I turn right around and walk out. I want nothing to do with an eating establishment that can’t at least spring for a realistic rendition of chicken yakisoba hand painted by Michelangelo himself.

Photoshop basically destroyed a centuries-old artistic tradition of depicting six gyoza on a white plate. Now with all this AI nonsense, you might as well just make your food at home rather than stare at yet another “six finger hipster eating a vegetable spring roll” cranked out by ChatGPT.

fn-motetoday at 12:48 PM

You forgot the /s.

Sadly, if it hadn’t gone on to DaVinci, I wouldn’t be sure.