logoalt Hacker News

Apple iPhone 18 Pro Camera test

110 pointsby luuyesterday at 12:00 AM109 commentsview on HN

Comments

matjayesterday at 3:00 PM

I'm surprised that in no reviews of the iPhone 18 camera there is mention of the bad quality bokeh, it has heavy ring shapes that looks like what you'd get from a cheap catadioptric lens.

Edit: e.g. the tree in one of the images in the page: https://www.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/PoleHDR_D...

show 2 replies
Cadwhiskertoday at 1:27 AM

The site is currently down (for me, at least):

https://web.archive.org/web/20260920202324/https://www.dxoma...

velcrovanyesterday at 4:02 PM

Someone should assemble a chain of iPhone camera review comparison images published over the years, 18 → 17, 17 → 16, 16 → 15 etc. showing how each year's new phone being so much better than the previous year's somehow becomes perceivably bad next to the next year's phone.

show 1 reply
azatomyesterday at 12:32 AM

Where is a comparing site where the exact same subject and lightening used? Why https://www.gsmarena.com/piccmp.php3 stopped it? I can only find these "trust me" reviews.

gyomuyesterday at 3:44 PM

> "DXOMARK’s objective measurements and perceptual analyses"

Where are the measurements? All I see are vague generalities like "well-rendered images with improved contrast and natural-looking skin tones". I guess those are the "perceptual analyses"? Is there a "See full measurements" button I'm missing? How do they come up with numbers like "157 Portrait", "172 Outdoors"?

show 1 reply
ricardobeatyesterday at 3:21 PM

A little hard to interpret as the Huawei pictures are not cropped to the same frame. When zooming in the difference is less striking.

sharktheoneyesterday at 12:21 AM

Interesting to see what they got out of basically the same camera sensor. It seems largely just like way better denoising capabilities. Maybe that is why they needed the extra NPU in the A20 chip.

But even with that they are still behind Android phones, while they dominated some years ago

show 3 replies
FanaHOVAyesterday at 9:58 PM

Zooming in on a clock 4-500yds away and expecting a fully crisp image seems somewhat of a useless benchmark.

show 1 reply
urbandw311eryesterday at 8:18 PM

I’m not convinced that this is a particularly scientific or rigorous test of the cameras! Seems rather lacking in control variables, documented processes, actual measurements etc.

sgtyesterday at 3:11 PM

How does it compare to the Samsung flagship phone cameras? I have to say I was impressed by the Samsung cameras, although being Android based it's not really an option for me. It'd be like trading a Porsche 911 for a Pontiac Aztec.

show 2 replies
ThePhysicistyesterday at 2:55 PM

The Huawei model just uses AI based upscaling and filtering which is why the images look so sharp when zoomed in, that's not depicting reality though... You can also zoom into the moon on the night sky with these cameras and easily "resolve" details that are optically impossible to resolve with the camera lens as they are beyond the Abbe limit. At the very least they should compare RAW data in these posts, not the AI scaled slop most of these cameras produce nowadays.

show 4 replies
qmryesterday at 9:39 PM

My gripe with iPhone is hunting white balance. Always happening when I'm shooting video.

I wonder if newer phones / camera apps are better.

show 1 reply
sharktheoneyesterday at 12:22 AM

it tells something that the word "aperture" is only mentioned 3 times in the test

show 2 replies
Sharlinyesterday at 3:09 PM

> https://www.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DuoTable_...

Oh god that plasticization of the faces is absolutely horrifying. Like a bad image gen AI from 2022. Or reptilians wearing cheap rubber masks.

Edit: what's with the downvotes?

show 3 replies
lofaszvanittyesterday at 11:37 PM

Wait for cined's test. Here is the predecessor:

https://www.cined.com/lab-test-of-the-iphone-17-pro-rolling-...

brcmthrowawayyesterday at 8:31 PM

Vibe-reviewed.

miladyincontrolyesterday at 3:13 PM

Is it just me or in their initial photo the focus point is in a wildly different point. On the iphone it's prioritizing the foreground model, on the Huawei the background. Definitely noticeable based on hair, although the Huawei seems to oversharpen the face with iPhone doing a bit of the opposite.

mula64yesterday at 8:26 PM

Ok so let's hack it

trvzyesterday at 9:56 PM

I’ll pass on the opinion of a website that has not only a cookie banner, but a stupid modal.

show 1 reply