logoalt Hacker News

axegon_yesterday at 12:04 PM8 repliesview on HN

Ah, the "skill issue" argument again. Same crap aswhen everyonewas worshiping Musk 5-6 years ago, this time it's dario and altman with a claude/chatgpt mask. Crash can't come soon enough.


Replies

skybrianyesterday at 12:16 PM

And why wouldn’t writing software be a skill issue? Yes, it’s an annoying meme, but we should expect that there are better and worse ways to write software. It would be weird if everyone got the same results regardless of experience.

I’m doubtful that the author’s recommendation always work, but I do some similar things and they do seem to help.

show 3 replies
Sharlinyesterday at 12:19 PM

In a way it reminds me of the good old "if agile doesn't work for you, you're not doing agile right".

show 1 reply
hypferyesterday at 12:32 PM

It actually is though?

Though arguably more of a process and judgement issue than skill.

What makes LLM-generated code a bit special there is that misjudging how to deal with it seems to be what most people do. So the default is broken.

Whereas in prior iterations of "skill issue", the default was working.

post-ityesterday at 12:32 PM

What's a crash going to do? The internet didn't disappear after the dot com bubble popped.

CrimsonRainyesterday at 12:20 PM

It is indeed skill issue.

You don't think crash will happen because XYZ. You _wish_ for the crash because you are hateful of progress that you are not part of.

show 3 replies
mitxelayesterday at 12:50 PM

What were people worshipping Musk for 5-6 years ago?

rgoulteryesterday at 12:39 PM

LLMs are not magical tools which take slop as input, and produce well thought out documentation and tests and code as a result.

Over the last year, LLM coding agents gotten pretty good. It's no longer "if your results suck, you gotta try the latest and greatest model". You can get capable results on a wide variety of tasks, with a wide variety of models, used in a wide variety of ways.

ModernMechyesterday at 12:10 PM

I think the point is just it doesn’t have to get worse, so there are things you can do to prevent / change it if it is deteriorating.

show 1 reply