logoalt Hacker News

legostormtrooprtoday at 7:14 AM3 repliesview on HN

So if you know a book that has the information you need, you just need to upload it into the model to get the right answer.

Isn't that a bit circular - if you already know the authoritative source, why ask a model?


Replies

Calazontoday at 7:26 AM

Because it's faster.

I've done this on different topics - I know the answer is in a particular eBook/PDF/document, but for whatever reason it's not trivial to look it up. The model can do it a lot more quickly than I can, and then I can still verify the accuracy.

show 1 reply
theshrike79today at 7:57 AM

It's basically a fancy context aware ctrl-f to the book.

I use this regularly with RPG manuals. I _know_ the stuff, but don't remember every detail by heart. And just ctrl-f:ing through a Mörk/Pirate Borg -style PDF isn't really productive (they're "artistically" laid out). But I can just ask an AI bot that has the pdf indexed like "how does the medical kit work?" and it'll give me a summary along with the relevant rolls within seconds.

lconnell962today at 7:32 AM

Some of the more widely spread and tolerated LLM outputs seem to be AI slop replacing Journalism/Blog slop. Places where people complained about quality already, but tolerated it if important enough.

So to name some of the more common ones Translation, Summarization, and Reiteration of a source material.

Humans put spin on things, how much you trust a source might not reflect the source's factual accuracy. It might just mean you liked reading it better from one source than another.