logoalt Hacker News

NoMoreNicksLefttoday at 7:29 AM2 repliesview on HN

What facts do you think can change my preferences? I'm sitting here telling you I want apple pie, and you're harping on about how "kale salads have all the vitamins you need!". We're talking at each other, because you failed to understand. This isn't about what you think the facts are, but about what I want to happen. I can accept those as facts and it wouldn't change anything.


Replies

AuthAuthtoday at 9:38 AM

In your example you would be saying you want apple pie because it gives you all these vitamins. Then when told apple pie is not the answer and its actually kale you want them you immediately pivot to a different for ending up at apple pie.

Its the floating table. You knock all the legs of their argument down and their belief only gets stronger. They are not switched on.

show 1 reply
lazyasciiarttoday at 7:39 AM

This feels unrelated to anything else being said, unless you’re arguing that literally no arguments feature a factually incorrect position.