logoalt Hacker News

schacontoday at 9:42 AM0 repliesview on HN

It's much, much worse than that.

Yes, you do need to do that. However, there is also much more work after that.

Git will not intermingle SHA-256 and SHA-1 enabled repositories, even in things like submodules, so anything used in that manner will need to keep both versions into the indefinite future. If you rely on a submodule that has not yet converted, you will have to convert it yourself and try to keep it up to date, or the forge will have to automatically keep a bidirectional mirror (if you have submodules in various forges, you'll have to wait for all of them to do it), etc.

This means that every SHA referenced anywhere on the internet, in commit messages, in issues, in code comments is now invalid and needs a mapping to find the rewritten one for forever.

It also means that every commit signature ever made is now invalid and will probably have to be stripped from the rewritten new 256 history because it's impossible to resign everything.

Companies like Google and GitHub are working on keeping two versions of each repository so that there can be long stages of ecosystem migrations, but no matter what, it's going to be a huge pain for millions of developers for years to come.