logoalt Hacker News

duskdozertoday at 12:52 PM2 repliesview on HN

Why would I want to nag it and do all that when I could just do it correctly myself in the first place?


Replies

havnagiggletoday at 1:00 PM

That's like asking why senior/staff engineers tend to review more code than write themselves. In certain environments there's a scaling constraint, and you can generally have wider impact through oversite than typing at a keyboard yourself. That's not to say one is more worthy of your time or not, just that it's not unique to AI.

Generally though, you are also investing your time into leveling up junior engineers to take over responsibilities from you. I just never really see that happening with AI. Even as it gets "better" technically, there's no real growth pattern to its work and it doesn't understand ownership or responsibility.

But if scaling isn't a problem, then sure just write it yourself.

petesergeanttoday at 1:23 PM

Same reason you’d hire engineers rather than expecting the CTO to do all the programming?

It doesn’t take much effort to setup cross-agent reviews and automatic reviews for slop and accretion, while directing design decision questions back to the human to consider. I have had a considerable increase in throughput of code that I designed and made the important decisions about, and that I’m pleased with the quality of, although as always in these discussions, someone will be a long shortly to tell me that that implies I must be a terrible engineer.