logoalt Hacker News

Coulomb's law remains tricky to test at home

18 points • by surprisetalk • last Tuesday at 1:00 PM • 16 comments • view on HN

Comments

nh23423fefe • today at 3:17 PM

> But it's not at all obvious to me why the exponent a is 1 in nature

i think we can rule out any exponent just by dimensional analysis if you allow powers of q, then K has ambiguous units. Same reason you cant exponentiate unitful quantities

More specifically I think we can rule out even exponents by anti-symmetry of charge. That is q^2n = (-q)^2n which know is ruled out by experiment.

➕ show 4 replies
gmkiv • today at 5:33 PM

Oh, he's so close! He's already constructed an electroscope. Now he just needs to use that to perform Cavendish's experiment, and he'll have verified Coulomb's law.

sobellian • today at 4:58 PM

For two different indivisible charges, this is a bit slippery but I think a=1 by definition. How do we measure charge, practically speaking? By how much force is measured between it and a reference charge. So we take a=1 as a convention. But no experiment can disprove a=2 for indivisible charges as we would simply obtain charge through new units. For assemblies of charges the forces must add linearly due to conservation of momentum, so there we know a=1.

smallmancontrov • today at 3:00 PM

Cat + Packing Peanuts

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cat_demonstrating_st...

➕ show 1 reply
Lvl999Noob • today at 4:02 PM

Could you use an electromagnet and a metal ball to create a fixed charge? If you change the current in the electromagnet, that would change the intensity of the magnetic field. With the metal ball fixed in place nearby and a careful curve for the change of current, you could potentially have a constant charge remaining on the ball.

MengerSponge • today at 3:51 PM

It's probably easier to verify Gauss's Law, which then gives you Coulomb's law for free.

Direct verification of inverse square laws is hard! For electromagnetic interactions (ie Coulomb's law) you can use scattering. If you want to do a static experiment (Coulomb's Law the hard way or gravity) you probably need a torsion pendulum experiment. AFAIK the best in the world at that are at UW in the Eöt-Wash group: https://www.npl.washington.edu/eotwash/torsion-balances

NooneAtAll3 • today at 3:33 PM

> Supposedly, one way to make two equal charges is to charge one thing and then put it in contact with the other thing, so that the charge splits by symmetry. But then how would we check that indeed we have two equally charged things?

same as with making guaranteed flat surface - you make 3 and measure each pair

➕ show 2 replies