logoalt Hacker News

sanderjdtoday at 1:31 PM1 replyview on HN

It's fine to have preferences. The biggest problem with bikeshedding is the time spent (wasted) debating. But you don't have to debate the AI, you just tell it your preferences, and ideally encode them so that they are repeatable.


Replies

dcowtoday at 5:50 PM

Of course it's fine to have preferences. I think you missed the nuance. Bikeshedding implies the time is wasted because the topic wasn't important in the first place. The color of the bike shed, as it were, has nothing to do with the storing of the bikes.

I am equating the nerve that develops in people that get lost bikeshedding (wasting time on inconsequential parts of the problem) with fighting an llm on inconsequential implementation details.

We most certainly agree: what matters should always be the actual requirements (functional, security, performance, etc.) You can't bikeshed an important topic. Everything else is implementers decision. In my experience an experienced engineer understands the difference and trusts implementers to make the decisions that they do own.

show 1 reply