logoalt Hacker News

howunfortunatetoday at 2:00 PM2 repliesview on HN

Be fair to Socrates though.

We have significantly degraded in our ability to memorize e.g. epic poems or preserve oral traditions since the advent of writing.

I know that sounds trite in retrospect, given the benefits, and that's half the point. But there are real tradeoffs too! For example, culture has a LOT more generation-to-generation turnover as a result of literacy being common, making it unstable.


Replies

6LLvveMx2koXfwntoday at 2:21 PM

I think (?) my point was that Socrates equated Memory with Wisdom, and the invention of writing would impact Memory and thus Wisdom. I believe he was just plain wrong. Equating (manual) coding/code-review with Wisdom makes the same category error.

show 1 reply