logoalt Hacker News

sashank_1509today at 4:49 PM2 repliesview on HN

Maybe if we had a single human we talk to 24/7 at scale, we would get annoyed at his cadence and style. You need variety to not pick up on known patterns I assume, which a single model can’t replicate?


Replies

dgroshevtoday at 4:57 PM

No, it's just poor writing. Actionable points are buried inside the paragraphs and over-hedged, and one point is completely made up. Compare to a five second rewrite:

* Consider leaving a comment about the hard-coded Vercel target. It's not clear where does it come from.

* [This is just a bullshit point, because the domain is not "added to" Vercel, it's provided by Vercel]

* Are you sure that [CENSORED] is prod-only? The name suggests otherwise. [also, what "if you're reviewing this rather than just reading it" even means?]

show 1 reply
redox99today at 5:39 PM

Nah it's definitely a Claude thing. Other models even though they have their style are less annoying and less stereotypical.