logoalt Hacker News

gchamonlivetoday at 4:56 PM1 replyview on HN

> art is art if and only if it was made by humans, end to end

I disagree with your definition of art. One can use AI as a reference and the end result will still be art because it'll carry execution technique and the subjective perception of the artist. Saying otherwise would be like saying that electronic music isn't music because it's a computer producing the sound waves.

A better candidate would be "an object can be a work of art if and only if it wasn't made by machines end to end".


Replies

brendoelfrendotoday at 6:40 PM

Ha, that is a fair critique. Now, I do consider electronic music to be art; in that case, I consider the computer or synthesizer to be an instrument, and thus the creative output of a DAW is still the artist's creative output. There is definitely some sloppiness in how I defined my terms; unfortunately, I'm just not going to commit my afternoon to an iron-clad definition of art for an internet comment.

show 1 reply