logoalt Hacker News

otterleytoday at 2:50 AM2 repliesview on HN

Why? Do you believe free speech is a right only Americans should have? Or do you believe that people shouldn’t be free to evaluate competing points of view and decide for themselves?


Replies

lazidetoday at 3:39 AM

This seems like a variant of anti-self defense logic. ‘The other guy has a right to beat you in the face with a bat, as much as you have a right to take it’.

Hint: bussing in out of towners to astro-turf ‘town discussions’ is also seen as shitty.

A quick way to test this kind of thing is, if the roles were reversed, would they still be okay with it?

I guarantee you that China and Russia would absolutely not be okay with the US doing the same thing in their territory.

show 1 reply
bpodgurskytoday at 3:47 AM

I believe I live in the real world, where we have to figure out how to integrate abstract principles in a manner that allows our survival as a civilization.

Reciprocity is a pretty straightforward strategy — we can allow uninhibited competing points of view from countries that themselves allow unlimited speech internally.

show 1 reply