logoalt Hacker News

susliktoday at 11:11 AM2 repliesview on HN

But why do we need changes on the desktop? What was wrong with the desktops of Gnome 2 / Windows XP / Snow Leopard era? I'll never understand why we couldn't just stick with that - it felt that desktop was solved back then and is going downhill ever since, change for the sake of change, or maybe marketing to make things look prettier.


Replies

criddelltoday at 12:15 PM

I think the OS/2 Workplace Shell was probably the pinnacle. Everything since then has been a functional downgrade with nicer aesthetics (which matter!).

Telaneotoday at 11:15 AM

Very little was wrong with those. I'd be very happy if those were the default, plus a few niceties we've found since then.

But I'd also like us to discover more, to hopefully make the desktop better. The way to do that however, is not by forcing users to try whatever the hot new thing is. The old and known good needs to remain a viable option.