alt Hacker NewsThat or you hit some UB elsewhere that caused the compiler to assume things that you didn't follow.
Trying UBSAN and ASAN might have been worth it. I don't think comparing debug and release builds would have helped: could be buggy optimisations or UB in your code regardless of what the outcome of that test was.
In this case I was reading memory with a debugger and could see that it literally was the same object at the same memory address, but what I did not know was whether or not different parts of the code had different views of that field for some reason, or any number of other things that could have been causing the issue. Either way, it was super weird and frustrating.