logoalt Hacker News

amiga386 • today at 4:19 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> You can’t say it’s “not a policy issue” by pointing to literal lawyers who are using the law.

It's not a UK speech policing policy issue, the topic of your post. The criminal law doesn't support Arday using false claims of harrassment to deter journalists.

You could say it's a worldwide civil law policy issue in terms of barratry / SLAPPs / cost of litigation / etc. No country, certainly not the US, has sufficient protection for whistleblowers against well-resourced litigants, and it is they (not the UK criminal law) who are successfully chilling speech.


Replies

Aurornis • today at 4:35 PM

> It's not a UK speech policing policy issue

It's the thing we're talking about.

The UK law was used to get police involved and the police told the journalist to desist.

> You could say it's a worldwide civil law policy issue

The fact that lawsuits exist everywhere does not make it equal everywhere.

We're talking about the UK's specific laws.

➕ show 2 replies