logoalt Hacker News

t-writescode • yesterday at 9:39 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I'll quote you clearly.

> "People have free will. Bad people know what right and wrong is, and they chose wrong."[0]

Broader Context: In response to a commentary on how 'good and bad' can be complicated:

> "It's always someone else's fault."[1]

Broader-broader Context: Prison is punishment, etc.

So, a reasonable chain of thought here and paraphrase of what you've said is: "people know right from wrong" -> we're in the context of crime and punishment, so this is operating as a substitute for "they know what's legal and illegal". If it's not, it doesn't belong here, because at this point we should all know that legality != morality.

"and they chose wrong" -> therefore they chose the consequences - they chose punishment. The colloquial way of saying that is "they get what's coming to them".

So, while those weren't your words, was that your implicit statement? And if not, what is the implicit statement?

I ask because the people in those cells are real, and 23 of them died of heat.

  [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49834799
  [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49834226

Replies

WalterBright • yesterday at 10:08 PM

> at this point we should all know that legality != morality

Recall that I wrote this to you:

"I did not say there was no injustice happening. Nor did I say that all laws are just."