logoalt Hacker News

danhor • today at 3:38 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> The FAA has one of my favorite examples of thoughtful rulemaking. They haven't banned flying with a baby on your lap, because the extra cost would mean many parents would drive instead. Since driving is far less safe than flying, a ban would lead to more deaths. I'd love to see more of this "all things considered" thinking around bans.

In terms of CO2e, a familiy of 2 + a kid driving a car instead of flying results in quite a bit of less emissions. Depending on the assumed mortality per tonne CO2e, driving might lead to a lot less deaths.

This is of course quite unreliable data, but one example of just to say how "all things considered" is very hard and almost always still comes down to a judgement call.


Replies

changoplatanero • today at 3:39 PM

Of course, not everything needs to be decided by the FAA. Sometimes they could let people make decisions for themselves.

➕ show 1 reply