logoalt Hacker News

akersten • yesterday at 10:54 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

It's useful because it let's me see the decisions the model will make before it wastes a ton of time implementing them. The model is smarter now but that doesn't solve for underspecification if it guesses my intent wrong


Replies

bcherny • yesterday at 10:59 PM

Interesting, I don’t see this very often with the latest models. Are you using Opus 5.5/Fable 5.1?

Either way, plan mode isn’t going away. You can always /plan or ask Claude to enter plan mode. We might re-map the shift+tab keyboard shortcut to something else by default for people that don’t use plan mode.

➕ show 6 replies
brokencode • yesterday at 11:01 PM

You can just tell it to write out a plan.md file.

I greatly prefer this, since it lets me iterate on the plan with Claude for a while without it repeatedly asking if I’m ready to implement the plan.

Once I’m satisfied, I usually start a fresh session and tell it to implement the plan.

For smaller plans, you don’t need the file. Just ask it to come up with a plan. I don’t recall the last time it just started implementing if I only asked for a plan.

➕ show 2 replies
solarkraft • yesterday at 10:59 PM

But that’s just the value of planning, not having it be a special mode.

➕ show 1 reply
bityard • yesterday at 10:58 PM

> wastes a ton of time

It wastes a ton of tokens as well and those are not cheap.

zarzavat • yesterday at 11:04 PM

It’s not that planning is dead, but rather that planning has outgrown the simple “Plan Mode” feature as models have become capable of taking longer turns.

iamdanieljohns • yesterday at 10:55 PM

THIS.