alt Hacker NewsCalculators and computers are deterministic, they give the same output to the same output every time. Language models specifically are not. So it might give you are function that is correct, or a function that is not, or worse yet a function that behaves correctly, but introduces some god-awful bug down the line that can cause serious havoc. It is obvious that they need supervision, not only for output, but also sandboxing and various harnesses for them to not do any “oops, I deleted your codebase sry” kind of nonsense people post to Reddit.
So I think the problem is to determine which problems under what instructions we can safely give to a model application to solve and how we test the output for safety and functionality. This would create more usable and safe, albeit a bit more boring, AI-based applications alin to a calculator or general computer. Whether this is posswith current model architecture is another thing.
Replies
Humans (IQ of X, non deterministic) can write deterministic code.
AI (IQ of Y, non deterministic) can write deterministic code.
Y is going to keep increasing, while X will not.
> Calculators and computers are deterministic
How do you know?
Memory bits flip randomly. It's not a super rare thing either. You and me have experienced that many times without knowing. The only reason that computers feel deterministic is that we have error-correcting code to fix that. But in the most extreme cases, when multiple bits flip together, once "deterministic" program can generate unexpected output.
So why do you trust computers? Because statistically the case is just very unlikely. Therefore if AI is statistically unlikely to make mistakes there is no reason to not trust them.
[dead]
If you set the temperature 0, an LLM is also deterministic (same prompt -> same output every single time). We just don't do this because the LLM is not so smart in that mode. But "LLM is not so smart" is changing at Moore's law speeds.
Non-determinism is not an essential property of LLMs. It's an optimization that we've added intentionally.