logoalt Hacker News

zergrush • yesterday at 9:57 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

I just find it odd so many non-Japanese media and commentators weigh in on this.

Japan is not a multicultural country. You can't become Japanese through paperwork. It is very much through blood heritage, your language and cultural proficiency.

The bar to be Japanese is much higher than say Canadian or French. So why shouldn't they create laws that is aimed at benefiting themselves and their country without depending on foreigners?

Also if you have a business and you don't have $125,000 you are not going to make it in Canada or America either.


Replies

dgellow • yesterday at 10:01 PM

> I just find it odd so many non-Japanese media and commentators weigh in on this

What is odd about it? People comment on every country immigration policies. Why would Japan get a special exemption

QGQBGdeZREunxLe • yesterday at 10:02 PM

> Also if you have a business and you don't have $125,000 you are not going to make it in Canada or America either.

I had less than $10k to my name when I moved to Canada. I have done very well since.

➕ show 1 reply
gozucito • yesterday at 10:56 PM

Through blood heritage ?

Explain why the blood is needed. Is it perhaps because Japan uses a different type of oxygen that needs different hemoglobin?

Noe2097 • yesterday at 10:24 PM

It feels normal in a globalized world for commentators around the globe to observe and weigh in on the decisions of any country, especially one of such economic importance and cultural significance as Japan.

That being said, I wholeheartedly agree on your points regarding Japan not being a multi-cultural country. And this, indeed, is rarely (if ever) mentioned in articles such as the one posted here.

Japan is an island. It has always been and not just from a geographical perspective. Its very culture and history are ones of isolation. The restrictions are not new, the perspective "Japan first" is not new - these have always been there, they are at the very core of the nation.

➕ show 4 replies