logoalt Hacker News

qarl • today at 9:13 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

> That's not been legally established

100% of the rulings agree with me.

The piracy is not in question. It is unarguably copyright violation.

But that's not what anyone means in this context. Training is what everyone means.

> The law is the law, there can't be different law for corporations with billions in backing.

I didn't say otherwise. That's a straw man.


Replies

trompetenaccoun • today at 9:18 AM

So we agree they have violated copyright at a much larger scale than LibGen, yet they call LibGen "sketchy" for doing the same thing? Absurd, what exactly are we arguing here?

➕ show 1 reply
latexr • today at 9:40 AM

So, which is it? First you said it was fair use, now you’re saying it’s unarguably copyright violation. You can’t have it both ways.

➕ show 1 reply