logoalt Hacker News

ChickeNES • today at 10:13 AM • 6 replies • view on HN

You’re arguing with a scenario you invented, then treating its most deranged conclusion as evidence.


Replies

hodgehog11 • today at 10:23 AM

I continue to be shocked at how people outright disregard these kinds of possibilities as pure science fiction. This is literally the objective of the ultrawealthy, it is the natural extrapolation of the early events of the industrial revolution projected onto a near-future world, and given current trends, the only hope of it not happening is that people everywhere realize what is happening and use our remaining capacity to steal power back. Feudalism is the natural state of mankind, and has been for thousands of years.

I am very hopeful that such scenarios would not come to pass, but dismissing them outright puts us on the path toward them.

➕ show 3 replies
throwaway173738 • today at 1:16 PM

Have you listened to how people like Altman and Thiel talk? They do not seem to care about regular people except as objects to be subjugated. This kind of talk is also how we get a president that claims repeatedly to want an end to war and then starts one. When people tell you who they are and what they’re about, listen.

spockz • today at 10:29 AM

I read it more as a sarcastic reflection on the state of the world by the author rather than that the author believes what he write himself or agrees with it. It is a debating technique to push a contrary argument to the extreme to see where the balance lies.

freecodeio • today at 11:47 AM

I don't think billionaires hating the poor is an invented scenario, the writing is on the wall when you open top 100 richest people

robotpepi • today at 10:35 AM

please tell us how you imagine things

well_ackshually • today at 12:00 PM

No, it's the only logical conclusion when the only thing you do is "end human labor" without going through the necessary steps of "dismantle capitalism", "guillotine every billionaire", "rework every method of redistribution we have", "completely rethink our methods of how power is distributed" and "provide meaningful occupations to every person on the planet".

Human labor disappears tomorrow, Peter Thiel's first dream is to see if you can still be useful when made into a paste.