logoalt Hacker News

ivanmontillam • yesterday at 9:46 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

> - Gmail - same

Gmail is not particularly difficult in terms of software engineering. The moat with email servers is IP address reputation.

I could, today, install Postfix SMTP and some IMAP as well, and watch my email all go to spam directly, if delivered at all (ISP might block them).


Replies

bubblemoth • yesterday at 9:54 PM

I use a reputable email provider (Mailbox.org) and my emails often end up in the spam of Gmail users.

katzenq • yesterday at 9:54 PM

FWIW, I've done exactly this + DKIM & DMARC on a residential IP and was able to deliver to Gmail & Protonmail with no problem, but didn't test it long term. Same with a server on AWS. I'm not sure if self hosting email is an overblown problem or I've just been very lucky somehow. Obviously it's still a big issue if for ex. Outlook's spam filters happened to be slightly more sensitive and dropped my mail; I never encountered issues but eventually I just used a custom domain via Proton for peace of mind.

➕ show 1 reply