logoalt Hacker News

username_my1 • today at 2:27 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Yeah I have a well established ... well designed codebase that I had before agentic coding and it does support horizental scaling (more services integrations doing more or less the same).

I got lazy around claude fable and astra, and asked them to work in loop (pick specified issue, develop it, qa it ...) have a separate CTO checking on arch.

at the end both models swore that the code is perfect and well designed and nothing is lacking.

I ran the software and it suddenly started writing large amount of data to CSV files instead of the typical DB usage.

AI decided to use csv for testing, and just drifted away. 0 regards to the actual project, 0 regards to common sense.

anecdotal but really weird, the project category is rather standard, I wouldn't accept such a mistake from a junior developer.


Replies

fingerlocks • today at 2:54 PM

Similar experience with a game engine. While working on one isolated component, like the render pipeline, a portion of the backing sparse data buffers were effectively duplicated with a different ABI. It’s like it forgot how to query meshes and game state, then assumed the plumbing didn’t exist so it was all rebuilt from scratch.

It compiled and ran just fine. If you weren’t reviewing the code holistically or keeping tight book keeping of your allocations you would not have noticed. Every single commit in isolation looks perfect. Very eye-opening