logoalt Hacker News

ex-aws-dude • yesterday at 7:15 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

If I do the same task 100 times I'm not going to suddenly do it crazily different at time 101 because I've built in the memory of how to do it

There is no RNG involved when I decide to push vs pull the unlabeled door to my building every morning, it becomes deterministic because its baked into memory

You can put stuff in context to deal with this but you can't do that for everything, its not practical and you would blow the context window


Replies

ben_w • yesterday at 8:37 PM

> If I do the same task 100 times I'm not going to suddenly do it crazily different at time 101 because I've built in the memory of how to do it

You, me, everyone, we all fail tasks with some non-zero probability, including tasks we've done many times before. This is literally why typos happen. We don't always catch the typos we make, this is literally why spellcheck exists. We don't always catch logical errors etc., this is literally why professional writers work with professional editors. We don't always spot errors in code we write; this was why compiler errors have to exist at one level, why unit tests and integration tests exist at another, and why despite automated tests we have QA departments.

Statistically speaking, you as a human will have made more comprehension errors reading that paragraph than even LLMs a few years back.

Not zero, just fewer. They're not magic and neither are we.

> There is no RNG involved when I decide to push vs pull the unlabeled door to my building every morning, it becomes deterministic because its baked into memory

There's a lot of random inputs into human behaviour. How much they become random outputs is a similar question as for AI. But like I said, typos are a trivial existence proof of humans making randomised errors on a thing they've done many times before. Timing error at random and a "the" becomes a "teh".

Here's one for gross failure modes being random: Small (and apparently random) groups of neurons in your (and all animal) brains briefly enter sleep-like states even while you remain apparently awake. This starts well before you even feel tired. And like I said, looks to be random.

Your memories are not "baked" at any point; they're made of and by cells doing chemistry. Your entire body is a trillion small bags of chemicals that communicate with each other by leaking out signalling molecules and electrochemical gradients into each other's water supply, and this goes wrong sometimes. Human memory is known to be fallible, and also manipulable after the fact.

➕ show 1 reply