logoalt Hacker News

skeletal88 • yesterday at 1:51 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

This is some kind of totally wrong reporting. Maybe some other country was meant, or the author mixed us up with Elbonia from Dilbert.

We do not have issues with electricity here or planned power cuts or whatever else.

I would like to see where this professor got his data for losses from. Maybe his data is flawed.


Replies

croisillon • yesterday at 1:59 PM

i dunno, if you follow the link to https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.ELC.LOSS.ZS?end=2024... you see Estonia has high distribution losses?

➕ show 2 replies
zeristor • yesterday at 7:05 PM

I did query ChatGPT and it seemingly wrong headedly suggested that Estonia had closed lots of Oil Shale power which it did have, I am not too up on this.

I did push back hard saying that that's not the same as what the article talked about at all.

The thing is if the World Bank is making statistics people are basing decisions on this is an issue.

"Oh, you sweet summer child"

dlisboa • yesterday at 2:54 PM

The article also says Brazil's "problems look like Delhi’s 25 years ago", which is very incorrect from what they're describing. Almost none of what is described in the article happened in Brazil 20 years ago, let alone today. Energy theft, for instance, happens here but at a minuscule scale compared to what's on the article.

I also doubt Estonia has any of these issues whatsoever, like energy theft.

It really seems like a vibecoded article with numbers informing incorrect conclusions. Perhaps with a dash of nationalistic pride. Unfortunate from IEEE.