logoalt Hacker News

hobo123 • yesterday at 3:57 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Generics is always claimed to be a reason, but nutrition also runs in families.

It's like saying BRCA1 causes breast cancer, but 90% of cases don't involve the gene, and many people with the gene don't get cancer.

I'm not saying it can't be a reason, but it looks like it's a common and maybe convenient excuse.


Replies

sandworm101 • yesterday at 4:03 PM

There is an easy line to draw between the two. "Family history", which includes eating/smoking/drinking habits, follows habitation. Genetics follows blood. So differences between bloodlines easily stand apart from family trends.