logoalt Hacker News

wrs • today at 8:25 PM • 10 replies • view on HN

I’m a CMU SCS alum (actually I predate SCS being a full school). Please, someone make me feel better about this. They’re renaming the school after this person.


Replies

Maken • today at 8:41 PM

Who cares? The entire university was named after the first guy who handed them money. It's their oldest tradition.

➕ show 1 reply
method_capital • today at 8:36 PM

Sure. It's $3B for your school. Who gives a shit what names the buildings have on them. I'll never understand you whiners.

$2B for new Miami campus (could have been in NYC, but well ...) $1B - split w $500M for CS Dept - for Pittsburg campus

"CMU Miami will invert the traditional higher education model by organizing learning and inquiry around societal challenges rather than academic majors. It will be entirely designed and built — from first blueprints to final beam — to drive revolutionary breakthroughs that address society’s defining challenges."

➕ show 2 replies
andrewla • today at 9:06 PM

They're not "renaming" it -- they're "naming" it, right? The School of Computer Science is not currently named for anyone, and his $1B puts his name on the school. It's not like they're changing CMU to KGU.

lanthissa • today at 9:59 PM

net net, 3 billion dollars is going out of of a rich persons pocket and into education.

thats a good thing.

also a cmu grad claiming the morality of the money going into education and naming rights matter is hilarious.

both its founders were worse than ken, and again at least hte money went to something good.

hooloovoo_zoo • today at 8:48 PM

In my experience students will just keep using the old name (sometimes even the name before the old name) in perpetuity. With regard to the new campus, satellite campuses never carry the prestige of the mothership, for schools or companies.

monknomo • today at 8:46 PM

I'm right there with you.

Renaming after this guy?

Miami?!

wqtz • today at 9:10 PM

Do names really matter? Half of all Canadian universities has a building or a faculty named after "Schulich". Most people do not know who that person is.

ro_bit • today at 8:35 PM

Who is he?

➕ show 4 replies
alephnerd • today at 8:41 PM

Yes and?

You went to a school who's founder was a robber baron (Carnegie) who deployed the army to put down a strike [0] and who's other founder (Mellon) caused the Great Depression [1] and whose family funded Trump 2 [2].

Alternatively, be happy CMU has more capital to continue to build programs.

Edit: can't reply

> To be fair, the Trumper is a different Mellon

It's the same family and Timothy Mellon is a direct descendent and heir of Andrew Mellon's

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike

[1] - https://time.com/archive/6757394/the-cabinet-death-of-mellon...

[2] - https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9eed9g3vlyo

➕ show 1 reply