logoalt Hacker News

godwinson__4-8 • today at 7:14 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

How so?

Could you defend your claim if the exception for war was confined to non surrendering enemy combatants? After all, I did not take the comment on "except war" to envisage the slaughter of civilians or execution of POWs.


Replies

pfannkuchen • today at 7:29 AM

I mean if it was a just war I don’t disagree, but people on both sides of every modern war I can think of deserved to die a lot less than people who commit whatever sort of crime still lands you on death row these days (with the possible exception of the actual leadership in a small number of those wars but still not many).

➕ show 1 reply