logoalt Hacker News

crote • yesterday at 9:15 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Which is considered a Really Bad Idea because tags aren't immutable, so there's absolutely zero guarantee that it'll point to the same commit a few months from now.

The GitHub Actions ecosystem found out the hard way, through some rather high-profile compromises. They hotfixed it by adding "immutable tags" to their platform, and are now working on adding a lockfile to... easily reference a commit hash.


Replies

PunchyHamster • yesterday at 11:55 PM

well if you use a knife to stab your fingers that's not a knife's fault

repo can also rewrite existing commit and you again won't be able to retrieve it so switching to commit IDs only lowers the level of failure somewhat

➕ show 1 reply