logoalt Hacker News

theoreticalmal • yesterday at 3:52 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

Do you have any thoughts as to why the FBI disagrees with your perspective?

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64806903


Replies

toast0 • yesterday at 4:33 AM

Is the US FBI a credible investigator for something like this?

a) I don't know that they have the right skills to track down patient zero of a disease.

b) They certainly don't have jurisdiction to do such an investigation in a foreign country, unless invited, and there's no way they were invited.

I strongly doubt we'll ever see a good answer on this, unless we get very lucky and some random research sample is looked at later that shows detection months earlier in a different location or if the Chinese did a good investigation and kept it quiet, but it leaks in a couple decades.

A timely and thorough investigation might have been able to determine an origin, but the US FBI certainly didn't do one.

➕ show 1 reply
bix6 • yesterday at 4:00 AM

I don’t but this guy in your article does

> A natural origin is still the more likely theory, said Professor David Robertson, head of viral genomics and bioinformatics at University of Glasgow.

➕ show 1 reply
tzs • yesterday at 4:59 AM

Your link also says

>> And other US government agencies have drawn differing conclusions to the FBI's.

alexnewman • yesterday at 4:07 AM

They don’t disagree. They don’t know. They just said what’s most likely. They don’t even give a %

➕ show 1 reply