logoalt Hacker News

shlant • yesterday at 12:18 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> I find it odd that you would cite an American intelligence report right after implying that America is authoritarian and autocratic. You can't have it both ways.

I'm not sure if you just aren't engaging with what is being said or are not reading the full post - he only shared that link IN RESPONSE TO you appealing to intelligence services. Read again:

"I don't think intelligence services are equipped to do this. >>>BUT if we go by who has the better data<<<"

He is saying "well IF we ARE going by intelligence services because YOU made that argument, then what about this?"


Replies

Gareth321 • yesterday at 1:59 PM

You missed his first two sentences:

> > China is an authoritarian, autocratic state.

> As opposed to current America?

He is implying that America is also an authoritarian, autocratic state. This was in response to my comment explaining why China will not comply with investigations. He is arguing that America cannot be trusted to provide accurate information, or comply with investigations. He argues this first, then attempts to argue that America is a more trustworthy source than Germany.

➕ show 1 reply