logoalt Hacker News

Texas city demands $2M for public records on Flock usage

176 points • by 01-_- • yesterday at 10:05 PM • 27 comments • view on HN

Comments

chaps • yesterday at 11:37 PM

Been there with a 33M cost estimate [1]. If the requester is reading this -- hold them to it and request a much smaller but still significant amount of records. Use that as the foundation for "how much time it actually takes". Another option is to get clever with helping them with means and modes of review/redaction. This is how I got the email metadata for 6M emails from Houston for example.

Another example from Vermont's governor's office: https://www.muckrock.com/foi/vermont-80/email-metadata-55744...

Happy to help more but I'll probably be unavailable tonight.

[1] https://mchap.io/that-time-the-city-of-seattle-accidentally-...

➕ show 6 replies
chao- • today at 2:31 AM

Original article specific to the $2.3M invoice:

https://www.texastribune.org/2026/10/05/texas-flock-cameras-...

Less egregious, but still egregious, a few weeks ago a local news investigator in Houston was quoted $121,000 for public records request related to Flock cameras:

https://www.click2houston.com/news/local/2026/09/24/harris-c...

therealdrag0 • yesterday at 11:50 PM

FOIA requests that have to be redacted are labor intensive. However, flock shouldn’t need to be redacted right? They’re just public webcams. Lots of those already exist and many stream live.

➕ show 1 reply
nilamo • yesterday at 11:39 PM

If the data is so difficult to get, that it's unreasonable to get, just get rid of flock then. You're already not getting any benefit.

Unless... no, that couldn't have been a lie, could it? The government would never try to overcharge anyone, right?

WokeUp420 • today at 1:34 AM

Texas sure does a lot of treading for being the don't tread on me capital

➕ show 1 reply
jt2190 • today at 3:07 AM

Headline should read “North Richland Hills TX…” Texas City TX is near Galveston. ;)

AngryData • yesterday at 11:26 PM

All digital government records should already be freely distributed. This is basically the same thing as poll extortion tax. You want to use your rights? Then pay up! Oh you didn't go away yet? Pay up even more!

➕ show 2 replies
aiXis • today at 6:12 AM

[flagged]