logoalt Hacker News

franga2000 • today at 6:47 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

Google: scans all books, people can search for them, find little snippets, see the title and author, buy the book to read it

AI: scans all art, people can ask it to produce art they're searching for, no reference to the original or its author, people no longer pay artists/designers/...

I think there's a very obvious distinction there. The whole purpose of copyright is ensuring the financial viability of creating works. AI slop is a direct market substitute for the originals it ate up for training, so it goes directly against that. Meanwhile, search actually improves the reach of works and, well, snippets and summaries are somewhere in between...


Replies

musicale • today at 7:27 AM

> The whole purpose of copyright is ensuring the financial viability of creating works

In the US it is "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts".

Of course, it was also supposed to be a limited-time monopoly rather than perpetual...