logoalt Hacker News

SyneRyder • today at 1:51 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

You've got to think the comments about "good enough" are people who have not yet tried Opus 5.5. I haven't been this struck by a step change since 4.5/4.6. It's a bigger jump even than when Fable first arrived.

As for Mistral - I got really excited when they said Large 4 was focusing on being #1 in cybersecurity, because that's somewhere that they genuinely could edge out Anthropic & OpenAI. Have it actually solve problems, instead of Anthropic flagging "you tried to find a null pointer exception bug in your own code, we're now reporting you to the US government". But on the Mistral benchmarks I'm seeing, this looks very disappointing, but at least they haven't entirely given up. I genuinely thought Mistral had given up on new general models. They need to learn the bitter lesson all over again.


Replies

Systemerror7A69 • today at 2:03 PM

I feel like the "good enough" argument isn't about how big the gap between models is but about how good they are at solving the tasks at hand.

The capabilities of all models increasing so much all the time means there are simply less and less tasks you need a frontier model for.

Even if Opus 5.5 is 500x better than Deepseek, if deepseek can solve all my problems, why do I need to pay for more?

➕ show 2 replies
eigenspace • today at 2:16 PM

I use Opus 5.5 daily for my job. I am aware (and in awe of) it's capabilities.

Look at the context in which I used that term 'good enough'.

What i was saying is that there are tasks for which a dumber model can be good enough, and for organizations with sovereignty/ privacy concerns, those concerns can be strong enough to incentivize the use of a dumber model.

skerit • today at 2:06 PM

> I haven't been this struck by a step change since 4.5/4.6. It's a bigger jump even than when Fable first arrived.

I had the exact same experience. And unlike Fable, it doesn't gobble up your entire usage limit in a few hours.

I always wonder what the "good enough" people are actually using it for.

➕ show 2 replies