logoalt Hacker News

Arainach • today at 6:56 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

What does that even mean? People are deciding to have kids because they believe it's too expensive, full stop. What's your counterclaim - they're bad at math and could afford it but think they can't? That if you forced a child on them they could actually suffer through it?


Replies

gampleman • today at 9:30 AM

Generally speaking countries that have tried to do something about their abysmal birth rates (Hungary, Czechia, etc) by putting in substantial economic incentives (i.e. 4 years of maternity, free accomodation, etc), have found that it moved the needle very little and certainly there can't be much talk of reversing the trend.

Also, I believe that our culture of over-parenting (and therefore many of the associated costs) is a _consequence_ of having fewer children, not the cause. If you put all your reproductive eggs in one basket, you are motivated to overprotect them. That makes a culture of (at least from a historical perspective) insane parenting demands that simply don't scale.

➕ show 1 reply
azan_ • today at 9:32 AM

Obviously the truth is that what people say and what people actually do are two different things. In case of having children we actually have proof for that!

> That if you forced a child on them they could actually suffer through it?

Absolutely, that’s how it always worked before we’ve had good contraception .

➕ show 1 reply