logoalt Hacker News

fennecfoxy • yesterday at 10:35 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

I find their (your?) example of using it as a separate API for expressions a bit odd. If you're already outputting voice surely other metadata could be outputted at the same time?

In text mode I'd use structured output for this, or even get away with instructing the model to [emote] or even just map emojis to emotes.

Great demo though, I'm going to try out the image stuff now. Super rad that it's multimodal decision making; "does this pipe need to be inspected?"->"yes","I want a closer look","no" etc!

Edit: impressive stuff! I gave it a bunch of examples: - things that humans should/should not eat and it got this correct (including rejecting rat poison) - probability staff member should be called to a train platform (people standing vs. child looking over the edge)


Replies

fennecfoxy • yesterday at 1:49 PM

I was curious about whether or not it could validate reasoning (because I don't have the time at the moment to try to slam together a hybrid llm+decision model that uses decision on its reasoning before output).

It fails this example: "Given the context, and focusing on accuracy and efficiency, does the reasoning make sense."

Input: "Context: supplementary: {toolName: "get_weather", fetched: "2 minutes ago", currentWeather: "sunny and 25 degrees celcius"} user: hello how are you? assistant: I'm good, what can I do for you? user: what's the weather? Reasoning: the user is asking about the weather, so I should call the get_weather tool"

Output: 100% (expecting 0% since the requested data is available in context and not stale).

Prompt "Should the tool be called" also fails.

But the prompt: "Does the reasoning make sense given: - Facts and information available in the context - Requirements for efficiency in tool calling - Requirements for tool arguments to be provided only by the user" works pretty fine, it's mostly points 1 and 3 that give it the correct behaviour.

Fun stuff. I suppose for these decision models reasoning isn't enabled? It would explain why logic puzzles that require several steps to make a decision don't really do so well. It gets the carwash problem fine, but fails on logic problems such as selecting which word from a list where at least one letter appears in another word from the list.

➕ show 1 reply