logoalt Hacker News

notpushkin • yesterday at 6:39 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

> The URL is the app

LLM-speak is a huge turn off to me (and a lot of other people here, from my interactions), so the fact that your submission title is AI-generated is... sorry, I have no words. I don’t even care that much about the code, but please write prose by hand, in your own voice, if you want us to read it.

Edit: rephrased the last sentence. Also, here’s my take on the title:

> Show HN: Bigwords.page – turn any screen into a sign, controlled by the URL params


Replies

rendleflag • yesterday at 6:52 PM

Let me guess, you saw the `–` and thought "Clearly no human uses the em dash. It must all be AI".

I looked over the website and their github page and saw no indication of AI usage. I'm not saying it wasn't used, but unless you have actual evidence, then please point it out.

➕ show 4 replies
dylanhouli • yesterday at 6:44 PM

Wait how is "The URL is the app" LLM-speak? Genuine question, sounded fine to me when I read it, not sure what a better way to phrase it would be

➕ show 2 replies
rpdillon • yesterday at 6:45 PM

Yeah, the issue here is that the URL is not the app.

This is basically a differently-shaped https://github.com/antonmedv/textarea

Cool idea, but agree that fixing actual mistakes in the title is a worthwhile use of time.

okaleniuk • yesterday at 7:08 PM

Donald Knuth once said "Jon Bentley probably hit the nail on the head when he once was asked why literate programming hasn’t taken the whole world by storm. He observed that a small percentage of the world’s population is good at programming, and a small percentage is good at writing; apparently I am asking everybody to be in both subsets."

Get off your high horse. Not everybody studied to write prose, not everybody was born American to begin with. If LLMs helps programmers get heard - good. That's probably the best usage for them anyway.

➕ show 3 replies