logoalt Hacker News

bondarchuk • today at 9:32 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

So did Franklin provably realize the double-helix structure of DNA first or not? A lot of beating about the bush here but the article stops just short of actually explicitly making the claim it's working so hard to imply, AFAICT...

(edit: should note the HN submission title (at present "Despite what Watson said, Rosalind Franklin understood structure of DNA first") does not actually occur in TFA)


Replies

gumby • today at 10:14 PM

The original title was too long and then when I considered how to edit it I realized that the original title was too obscure for anyone not steeped in that particular literature (“photo 51”)

kraken_cult • today at 10:11 PM

[dead]

➕ show 1 reply
burnte • today at 9:43 PM

She totally did. She was the crystallography expert, she understood the meaning of the results immediately. She died and had no one to defend her so W&C were left with the credit, as was normal in the 50s and 60s (and 70s, 80s, 90s, etc).

➕ show 1 reply