logoalt Hacker News

droidjj • today at 1:05 PM • 9 replies • view on HN

If you haven’t read the book yet, I’m tempted to warn you against opening the visualization. Part of the joy of reading this book is letting your mind’s eye run wild, and I fear if I read it for the first time after toying with this site, I’d be remembering the cities rather than conjuring them.


Replies

vanadium1st • today at 1:22 PM

That is the exact problem with the city of Dinipro.

Citizens of this city high in the sky imagine it so fully in their minds that no one there needs to open their eyes to walk the streets and live their normal lives. But if one makes the mistake of opening their eyes and tries to see the city directly, they would immediately fall through the clouds to the ground deep below.

➕ show 1 reply
losvedir • today at 1:38 PM

I heartily recommend the audiobook, narrated by John Lee.

The book is a trip and the dreamy sort of narration matched it perfectly. My wife and I would spend evenings listening to one city at a time, on a walk around our little park, one headphone in each ear. I don't know if it was just the environment or the time in our lives, but we both really look back fondly on this book.

➕ show 1 reply
stared • today at 2:01 PM

I fully agree, thank you for this warning.

How Opus 5.5 imagines these cities is a question for Opus. The real experience is how we imagine - and I believe there are no two people who have exactly the same mental image of an invisible city.

DennisP • today at 3:02 PM

Checking Amazon, several of the available editions are illustrated, which I suppose would have the same problem.

mcphage • today at 2:49 PM

> I’d be remembering the cities rather than conjuring them

Having looked at some of them (and it being one of my favorite books) ... it won't do that. These visualizations are as terrible as they are unnecessary.

drcongo • today at 2:24 PM

Don't worry about opening the GPT-6 Astra one though, those ones are so bad that your brain will immediately expunge them.

sixothree • today at 2:10 PM

Maybe the interactive link in the article for the optic focus can lead you on a fun journey instead. And the bottom-right of every visualization is a link to yet another fun diorama to explore.

miltonlost • today at 2:05 PM

It's a techie creating the torment nexus but the imagination version. No need to picture in your mind the invisible cities! Time to make them visible!!!

Talk about missing the entire point of the piece of literature.

FuturisticLover • today at 1:22 PM

I opened it because I had no idea what Invisible Cities meant here. I thought they might be some real cities that don't come up on maps.

The website gives you a good hint before opening up the visuals. So, I got an idea.

I don't really know about Marco Polo. My only knowledge comes from the Netflix series, which doesn't talk about these invisible cities.

➕ show 2 replies