logoalt Hacker News

lmz • today at 1:53 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

It may be so but the article does not claim that the strong foundation is the code, rather it seems to be product design, and design of other products, at that (the two predecessors, webapp and desktop app). No reason why you couldn't study existing products now and tell your agent to build something based on that.


Replies

scruple • today at 2:09 PM

This feels like a sleight of hand to me. The hard part of evolving Scribe and Web Scrapbook was discovering that a browser extension manipulating a local SQLite database was _the only_ architecture that could reconcile local offline persistence with live DOM scraping across arbitrary catalogs of academic data.

An agent can synthesize existing solutions but (because I see this failure mode at work constantly) it can't synthesize an architecture to resolve the sorts of tensions that the person prompting it doesn't yet understand (not that that is stopping anyone). You can't prompt it to build something if the operational primitives required to solve the problem haven't been mapped.

"Build a tool based on Scribe and Web Scrapbook" in 2003 would've made a fragile PHP wrapper because that's what the existing landscape looked like.

➕ show 1 reply