logoalt Hacker News

Palomides • today at 4:32 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

RFCs were originally formalization of what was being used in practice, home.arpa was chosen apparently for reasons of beauracratic convenience rather than what would best serve existing users, who all would prefer .lan and continue to do so since that was published in 2018


Replies

gumby • today at 5:40 PM

> RFCs were originally formalization of what was being used in practice

You may be confusing it with the IETF’s policy.

In early days of the RFCs, most started out as proposals, often but not always with some existing implementation as a jumping-off point to conversation (hence the name). I no longer remember why they started to be numbered and tracked, as the process naturally preceded that.

You can verify what I say by just reading some old ones at the rfc editor site.