logoalt Hacker News

tshaddox • today at 4:35 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Several notable dictators came to power through elections or through the existing legal appointment process. Of course it's more common for a dictator to come to power through a revolution, military coup, or civil war, but the way a political figure originally came to hold their political position is not really relevant to determining whether they are a dictator.


Replies

litoE • today at 4:59 PM

The more rational distinction between a dictator and a non-dictator is not how they came to power but how they can be removed from power.

➕ show 1 reply
xp84 • today at 4:46 PM

> the way a political figure originally came to hold their political position is not really relevant to determining whether they are a dictator

True, but Trump is a dictator because why? Because you disagree with the 77,304,296 people who elected him? Because he cracks unfunny jokes about running for re-election? Because he's corrupt? We've had corrupt Presidents before, but a dictator to me is someone who won't leave office. We do have a precedent of, despite the Jan. 6 looney toons (that he encouraged) trying to stop it, and despite all his dumb baseless lawsuits, Trump hopping on the helicopter and handing over power as scheduled. To me, that's the clear dividing line between an egomaniacal clown and a dictator.

I don't agree with a LOT of his 'policies,' (honestly sometimes describing his whims as policies is overstating it) but I would say the specific one being discussed here is not one of those open-and-shut dumb ideas. There are plenty of unemployed software engineers right here in the U.S. right now, and any US businesses saying they need H1Bs for most of those roles are full of crap.

➕ show 1 reply
gchamonlive • today at 4:47 PM

  it's more common for a dictator to come to power through a revolution, military coup, or civil war
Maybe in sheer number but the most notable autocratic regimen of the national socialist party in Germany began with a democratically elected leader.
➕ show 1 reply