logoalt Hacker News

hirako2000 • today at 4:40 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Given the stigma, someone won't give arguments that sounds racist.

What's racist? All visa programs are racist. Keep the border entirely close or let anyone who is not factually a criminal in.

Quota. It's racism.

We have eligibility even just for tourism based level of income. Some nations are exempt, some are not. That's perhaps even worse than racism. Lazy law enforcement, disguised as border control for safety.


Replies

gjskngnf • today at 5:03 PM

If your argument is that people who oppose broad work visa programs are secretly racist but won’t admit it, that’s unfalsifiable.

When a country has far more people seeking visas than it’s willing to admit, it needs some mechanism for deciding who gets in, whether that’s a lottery, eligibility requirements, or some combination. None of those is inherently racist. You seem to be arguing for a radical open borders policy that I doubt many people would support, in just about every country.