logoalt Hacker News

esalman • yesterday at 6:40 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

OP said 1 million unskilled relative per 65000 skilled worker.

In my case, spouses are siblings are all skilled workers, and we have not sponsored each other.

We have one kid, even he is advanced for his age in terms of reading/math.


Replies

rayiner • yesterday at 6:53 PM

Go to Little Bangladesh in Queens and tell me how all those people came here. It’s mathematically impossible unless they’re all illegal (which I don’t think is true) or it’s family reunification.

Each legal immigrant who becomes a citizen is the root of a tree that can continue indefinitely. If you come from anywhere other than India or China, it takes about 10 years to get citizenship from when you get your H1B. It took us less than 10. After that you can sponsor family for green cards directly. That person only needs about 6 years before they can get citizenship and start sponsoring their own family members. So it’s easy to see how we went from 10,000 Bangladeshis in the U.S. in 1990 to 300,000+ in just 35 years.

➕ show 2 replies
treis • yesterday at 7:10 PM

Okay, but in other cases it's not like that. They bring spouses, siblings, and parents who can turn bring their own spouses, siblings, and parents. That is severely curtailed these days by country restrictions so I agree that it's not 14 but it's higher than 1.