logoalt Hacker News

essai57 • today at 9:49 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

> Forgive me if I have no sympathy for current mathematicians who think this way. It's a pretty ugly kind of arrogance.

Thankfully, very few mathematicians share Hardy's opinion, just as very few share his opinion that "mathematics is a young man's game" (and indeed we now have prizes like the Abel Prize with no age limit).

In fact, many of the greatest mathematicians throughout history have taken exposition very seriously, e.g. Euclid, Euler, Lagrange, Cauchy, Dirichlet, Kolmogorov etc. all wrote textbooks. Many mathematicians today carry on that tradition of taking exposition seriously and write books and freely share their lecture notes.

So we should not take Hardy's opinion as representing the opinion of all mathematicians or even most mathematicians. In fact, Hardy's statement is somewhat self-contradictory since he himself wrote several expository books (e.g. "A Course of Pure Mathematics").


Replies

ModernMech • today at 12:32 PM

His statement was self-deprecating (in a not so endearing way), as he was referencing his young self as one of those first-rate minds but his current old self doing exposition as second-rate.

➕ show 1 reply