alt Hacker NewsI'd prefer AI companies don't decide who's "cleaning up pre-print papers". This should remain the job of mathematicians at universities, which I am happy to pay with my taxes. Ideally there was something like a Bermuda Principles declaration for mathematics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bermuda_Principles). This gave mathematicians even at poor universities and beyond the chance to participate in mathematical progress.
What do you think is gained, if AI companies manage "cleaning up"? Tax money?
Replies
> which I am happy to pay with my taxes
I'm not. To the extent my taxes are used for maths research (which is minute as a proportion of them) I want them to be used for the development of human mathematical understanding, culture and education, not trawling through a mountain of slop mechanically generated by a Silicon Valley startup that's about to IPO for trillions in the hope there might be some nuggets of insight hiding in there. If the latter is an activity with some value the startup in question can pay for it.
If OpenAI researchers are publishing shoddy papers, why in the world would anyone else be responsible for editing and cleaning up their shoddy papers?